Image created by Dr. Michael J. Miller
The presence of human waste in sewage overflow or stormwater runoff that ultimately finds its way into rivers and lakes is a major public health hazard. As a result, it is imperative that water bodies and samples are continuously tested for the presence of human fecal contamination.
Conventionally, testing for fecal contamination involves detecting fecal indicator bacteria (FIB), such as E. coli, by adding a drop of the sample water into a microbial culture medium. While FIB detection is cheap and simple, the method cannot be used to detect low-level contamination. This method is also incapable of determining the source of the contamination.
Microbial source tracking (MST) has the potential to overcome these challenges by detecting biomarkers—usually a protein, DNA, or RNA segment—that are specific to a host species. This allows MST to detect low-level contamination in wastewater, drinking water, lakes, etc., and identify the hosts, even when feces from multiple species are involved.
CrAss-like phages (CLPs), a class of viruses that infect bacteria (bacteriophages), are being hailed as a promising group of MST markers. CLPs are the most abundant bacteriophages in the human gut, and many CLPs are only found in human intestines (and feces). While there are several known groups of CLPs, only a single group, known as genus I, has been used as an MST marker. This prompts questions about whether the other group CLPs also function as MST markers and their viability compared to genus I.
Now, in a new study, Dr. Ok Kyung Koo and Dong Woo Kim from Chungnam National University, South Korea, in collaboration with Yang Jae Kang and Dong U Woo from Gyeongsang National University, have developed a novel MST detection method using CLPs that is capable of specifically detecting human feces-contaminated water. The method uses polymerase chain reaction (PCR) to detect CLP DNA, making the method cost-effective, selective, and easy-to-perform.
The study appears in Water Research.
"The primary aim of this study was to improve the efficacy and accuracy of detection methods used to assess specific fecal contamination," said Kim. "A robust MST marker would greatly help in our ability to mitigate health risks from fecal-contaminated water."
To test the efficacy of this method, the researchers collected fecal samples from selected human volunteers. Fecal samples from wild animals, such as dogs, deer, cats, birds, and raccoons, were also included in the experiment to test the specificity of the detection method. DNA extraction and sequencing was then performed to detect and classify CLP viral genes.
Thirteen distinct CLP groups were identified in human gut viruses. Using these CLPs as a template, the scientists then developed specific markers for their detection via PCR and tested them for their capacity to detect human fecal contamination.
The results of this study were encouraging. CLPs were found in 91.52% of human feces samples and were absent in all animal samples, except raccoons. Of the 13 CLP groups classified as identified, genus VI was present in 64.4% of samples, nearly double that of genus I (37.28%). Furthermore, all 13 CLP groups showed some similarity in their gene sequences, called the major head protein gene. This implied that a single marker could be used to detect multiple groups of contaminants.
"Our method shows that genus VI is a potent MST marker in the Korean population. Using PCR to detect MHP genes of genus VI CLPs, or even genus I, can be a practical approach towards monitoring human fecal contamination of water. I expect that our method can, over time, improve hygiene regulations and lower public health costs through the strategic screening of sewage, wastewater, and various environmental samples," Dr. Koo concludes.
In summary, the scientists concluded that CLPs, especially genus VI, could be used as viable MST markers that can specifically detect human fecal contamination. This is notable, as human-specific and selectively targeted MST markers can significantly impact hygiene regulations, lowering public health costs through their application in screening liver, sewage, wastewater, and various environmental samples.
More information: Dong Woo Kim et al, Development of a novel crAss-like phage detection method with a broad spectrum for microbial source tracking, Water Research (2024). DOI: 10.1016/j.watres.2024.122330
Abstract
CrAssphage has been recognized as the most abundant and human-specific bacteriophage in the human gut. Consequently, crAssphage has been used as a microbial source tracking (MST) marker to monitor human fecal contamination. Many crAss-like phages (CLPs) have been recently discovered, expanding the classification into the new order Crassvirales. This study aims to assess CLP prevalence in South Korea and develop a detection system for MST applications. Thirteen CLPs were identified in six human fecal samples and categorized into seven genera via metagenomic analysis. The major head protein (MHP) displayed increased sequence similarity within each genus. Eight PCR primer candidates, designed from MHP sequences, were evaluated in animal and human feces. CLPs were absent in animal feces except for those from raccoons, which hosted genera VI, VIIa, and VIIb. CLPs were detected in 91.52% (54/59) of humans, with genus VI (38 out of 59) showing the highest prevalence, nearly double that of p-crAssphage in genus I (22 out of 59). This study highlights genus VI as a potent MST marker, broadening the detection range for CLPs. Human-specific and selectively targeted MST markers can significantly impact hygiene regulations, lowering public health costs through their application in screening liver, sewage, wastewater, and various environmental samples.